PanOptix Pro vs Vivity: Which Cataract Lens Implant Is Better?
Patients researching premium cataract lenses often compare the PanOptix Pro lens and the Vivity Lens.
Although both lenses aim to reduce dependence on glasses, they use very different technologies.
Understanding these differences can help determine which lens might be right for you.
PanOptix Pro vs Vivity: Quick Comparison
| Feature | PanOptix Pro | Vivity |
|---|---|---|
| Lens Type | Trifocal | Extended Depth of Focus |
| Reading Vision | Excellent | Moderate |
| Intermediate Vision | Excellent | Very Good |
| Distance Vision | Excellent | Excellent |
| Halos | More Common | Less Common |
How PanOptix Pro Works
PanOptix Pro uses trifocal optics that split light into three focal points.
This allows patients to see clearly at:
- distance
- intermediate
- near
Because it provides strong reading vision, many patients can perform most tasks without glasses.
How Vivity Works
Vivity uses a different technology called extended depth of focus (EDOF).
Instead of splitting light into multiple focal points, it stretches the focus of light to create a continuous range of vision.
This typically results in:
- excellent distance vision
- very good intermediate vision
- some near vision
However, many patients still use reading glasses for small print.
Advantages of PanOptix Pro
PanOptix Pro may be ideal for patients who want:
- strong reading vision
- maximum independence from glasses
- full trifocal range of vision
Advantages of Vivity
Vivity may be ideal for patients who want:
- fewer halos and glare
- excellent night vision
- a more monofocal-like visual quality
Which Lens Should You Choose?
Patients who prioritize reading without glasses often prefer PanOptix Pro.
Patients who prioritize night driving and minimal halos often prefer Vivity.
About the Author Written by Dr. Michael Shumski, M.D., M.S.E.
Dr. Shumski is a board-certified ophthalmologist specializing in cataract & refractive surgery at Magruder Laser Vision in central Florida.
